Mon - Thurs 4pm - 10pm Fri 4pm - 11pm Sat 11am - 11pm Sun 11am - 10pm . 574-842-3331 Indiana's Best Pizza      Home » Desserts   Talk To Papa Login   DAILY SPECIALS!!!   Gift Cards   Pizza   Calzones   Entrees   Appetizers   Soups and Salads   Pasta   Sandwiches   Baskets   Drinks   Desserts   Sides Order Online or Call:   574-842-3331   Store Hours   My Account   FAQ   View Cart   Contact Us   Take & Bake   Papa's Story   Papa's Franchise      Talk to Papa Search Site Current Time: 5:58 AM Desserts   Treat your sweet tooth to one of our delicious after-diner specialties. Colossal Carrot Cake $13.95 Mile High Chocolate Cake $11.95 Carmel Appel Pie $3.95 Colossal Chocolate Chip Cookie $2.25 New York Cheesecake $4.95 Turtle Cheesecake $5.95 Cup of Ice Cream $2.25 Chocolate Sundae $3.50 Root Beer Float $4.00